How Increasing Interest Rates & Inflation Impact Commuted Pension Values in Canada

With the recent upswing in interest rates, the financial world has felt the ripples across every sector. It’s not just your average Joe feeling the pinch in their mortgage payments, or the stock market taking a hit. We’ve also seen a shift in the commuted value of pensions in a defined benefit plan, and it’s turning heads in the retirement industry.

Defined benefit plans, once the norm, have become something of a golden goose in the corporate world. They promise retirees a set amount each month, a seemingly unshakeable pillar of security in their twilight years. But with interest rates on the rise, the ground beneath these plans has started to shift. The commuted value – basically, what you’d get if you decided to take your money and run right now – has been on a roller coaster ride.

How Interest Rates Impact Your Pension Commuted Value

  • If interest rates are high, the present value (or commuted value) of a future cash flow decreases. This is because at high interest rates, you’d need less money today to generate a given amount in the future. For pensions, this means that the plan would need less money in hand today to cover future pension payments. Think of a teeter totter: rates up, commuted value down.
  • Conversely, if interest rates are low, you’d need a larger sum of money today to ensure the same future amount. So, the commuted value of the pension increases. We’ve seen $200k drop of commuted value amount since 2020.

Interest Rates on Bonds and Inflation

Interest rates have been rising as investors anticipate inflation. When inflation is expected to rise, investors require higher interest rates to compensate for the decrease in purchasing power of money over time. Rising interest rates mean bond yields increase, which is a cost to borrowers but beneficial for bond investors. Remember, interest rates are inflation + risk premium + profit. Short answer: interest rates ride inflation.

Unraveling Commuted Value & Increasing Interest Rates

So, let’s get down to the basics. Your Commuted Value (or CV for the cool kids) is essentially the current worth of all those future pension payments you’re slated to receive.  Essentially, it’s the “present-day value” of your future pension benefits. This calculation, rooted in the Pension Benefits Act, leans heavily on present value assessments of anticipated future pension payments.

Your commuted pension value is a treasure chest. It is what the experts, the actuaries, believe your pension is worth in today’s dollars. And oh boy, can it shine bright! A decent defined benefit pension might flaunt a commuted value anywhere from $250,000 to $1,000,000 or more. That’s a lot of zeros!

The commuted value of your defined benefit pension dances in sync with Government of Canada bonds’ yields, shifting daily. A drop in interest rates inflates the commuted value of a pension, while an increase does the opposite. Essentially, with rising interest rates, you’d need to allocate less today to achieve a specified future monthly income.

To break it down:

  • With a 1% interest rate, a $10,000 end-of-year payment would have a commuted value of $9,900.99 today (1/1.01*10,000).
  • At a 5% rate, the same payment’s present-day commuted value would drop to $9,523.90 (1/1.05*10,000).

For pensioners mulling over commuting their pension, this kind of shift is significant. Especially when extrapolated over a 30-year retirement life expectancy, your commuted value could potentially drop by hundreds of thousands of dollars!

Actuaries: The Whiz Kids Behind the Scenes

Ever heard of actuaries? They’re the math wizards figuring out financial risks, especially when it comes to pensions. When they crunch those numbers, they follow a playbook set by the Canadian Institute of Actuaries.

Calculating Commuted Value

How do they actually calculate commuted value? Present value is calculated as PV = FV / (1 + i)^n, where the present value equals the future value divided by one plus the expected interest rate over “n” number of years.

Without getting lost in the weeds, this formula translates to today’s present day value of future pension payouts. But here’s the deal – while this formula is a standard, companies might have their unique touch, making CV complex. We at Pension Solutions can NOT calculate your CV. Only your pension plan actuary can do that. But, we will help you understand and strategize.

Types of Pension Plans and CV

Defined Benefit vs. Defined Contribution Plans: The commuted value calculation is specific to defined benefit pensions. In these plans, you’re assured a set pension amount when you retire. Conversely, in defined contribution plans, your retirement benefits are uncertain, depending only on the performance of the investments your contributions are placed in.

Understanding Your Pension Statement’s CV

Retirement’s around the corner, or maybe you’re switching gears career-wise. Either way, that pension statement flaunting your CV figure is pivotal. Given the often-lush sums involved, it’s essential to strategize wisely.

Is My CV Enough for a Cozy Canadian Retirement? Many variables come into play – your health, where you want to nest, and the kind of lifestyle you’re eyeing. But remember, you’re in the driver’s seat of your spending. With the right strategy, you can make your retirement dreams a reality.

Check out our other blog articles about how much you need to retire comfortably in Canada.

Cash in Your CV: How to Play It

So, the big moment arrives, and you want to ‘cash out‘ your CV or and ‘take the lump sum‘, you’ve got choices:

  1. Slide it into a Locked-In Retirement Account (LIRA): Most of your CV can find a home here, but anything over the set limit becomes taxable cash.
  2. Boost Your Registered Retirement Savings Account (RRSP): If there’s room, tuck that taxable cash into an RRSP. If not, it’s time to talk taxes.
  3. Snap up a Life Annuity (aka. Copycat Annuity): Picture an annual income of a fixed sum, mirroring your pension perks. That’s the magic of annuities. In other words, draw your pension for life from Sun Life or Canada Life, not from your company.

Tax Implications: The Elephant in the Room

The commuted value’s hefty sum can be deceiving. There’s a taxing question (pun intended!) – how much of that sum actually ends up in your bank account?

Enter the Maximum Transfer Value (MTV). It’s a calculation that determines the portion of your commuted value that can be safely tucked into tax-advantaged accounts like LIRAs or LIFs.

This value is influenced by your yearly retirement benefits and your age. And while MTV keeps the taxman at bay, anything exceeding this amount will be taxed based on your income bracket.

In the world of large commuted values, it’s not unusual for 10% – 25% to be taxed at your personal rate. For larger amounts, this could push you into a higher bracket, meaning even more taxes. Ouch!

However, there’s a glimmer of hope! If you have room in your RRSP, you can shelter some of this from the tax storm. We’ve seen folks with $180k of available room in RRSP. Note that some employers allow direct transfer to your RRSP, other do not.

Got Your CV Estimate? Call in the Pros!

When that golden envelope (or more likely, email) from HR pops up with your CV estimate, it’s savvy to get a second opinion. Trusted Certified Financial Planners can be lifesavers here. Here at Pension Solutions, we offer a no cost consultation call to review your commuted pension value and explore your options, ensuring you get the full picture.

Click here to book a virtual consultation call.

You may also like...

Chat With A Certified Financial Planner - FREE!

Book a no-obligation 15-minute virtual Zoom consultation call with a Certified Financial Planner who can answer your pension and retirement questions and inform you of all your options!